Bullying in the Legal Profession

What Is Bullying in the Legal Profession?

Bullying in the legal profession is a widespread yet often overlooked issue that impacts lawyers across various settings. Unlike harassment, which is tied to legally protected characteristics, bullying encompasses inappropriate behaviors intended to intimidate, humiliate, or control another person. These behaviors may include:

• Verbal intimidation (e.g., name-calling, shouting, excessive criticism)
• Demeaning nonverbal behavior (e.g., eye-rolling, dismissive gestures)
• Unrealistic work demands and deadlines
• Spreading malicious rumors and false accusations
• Taking undue credit for someone else's work
• Exclusion from critical meetings or case discussions

A key factor in bullying is the power imbalance, where individuals in senior positions exert unrelenting aggression over their subordinates. Because anti-harassment laws do not cover workplace bullying unless tied to protected characteristics, there are often no formal legal recourses available, making it crucial to address the issue internally within legal organizations.

Learn more by watching Lawline's course "Bullying in the Legal Profession," presented by Roberta Liebenberg of Fine Kaplan & Black and Stephanie Scharf of Scharf Banks Marmor LLC.

How Prevalent Is Bullying in the Legal Profession?

A statewide study conducted by Red Bee Consulting in partnership with the Illinois Supreme Court Commission on Professionalism revealed staggering findings:

• 24% of lawyers surveyed experienced bullying within the past year.
  
• 38% of women lawyers reported being bullied compared to 15% of male lawyers.
  
• Lawyers with disabilities reported being bullied at a higher rate (38%) than lawyers without disabilities (24%). 
  
• 26% of lawyers reported being bullied into engaging in unethical or improper conduct.
  LGBTQ+ lawyers, lawyers with disabilities, and lawyers of color are more likely to change jobs due to bullying.

These findings emphasize that bullying is not an isolated issue—it is systemic, affecting all practice areas and legal settings, from law firms to government agencies and courtrooms.

Who Are the Perpetrators of Bullying?

Bullying in the legal profession is not limited to one demographic. The study found that perpetrators varied across:

• Senior lawyers within the same organization (31%)
  
• External lawyers (33%), such as opposing counsel
  
• Judges (14%), who were identified as bullies by attorneys practicing in court

Interestingly, 50% of surveyed lawyers admitted to engaging in bullying behaviors, often mirroring the types of behaviors reported by victims. This highlights the normalization of aggressive legal culture, where bullying is mistakenly seen as a "rite of passage."

What Are the Consequences of Bullying?

Impact on Lawyers

Bullying in the legal profession takes a severe toll on individual well-being, productivity, and career longevity:

• 54% experienced negative emotional effects, including anxiety and loss of confidence.
  
• 20% reported a decline in physical health due to stress-related conditions.
  
• 39% felt less productive at work, impacting firm efficiency.
  
• 18% left their jobs due to bullying, disproportionately affecting women, LGBTQ+ lawyers, and lawyers of color.

Impact on Legal Organizations

Firms and legal organizations that allow bullying to persist suffer in multiple ways:

• Increased turnover and talent loss (especially among diverse lawyers)
  
• Reduced productivity due to workplace tension and stress
  
• Damage to firm reputation, making recruitment difficult
  
• Higher attrition rates, requiring costly replacements and retraining

Why Is Bullying Underreported?

Despite its prevalence, bullying is rarely reported due to several factors:

• Fear of retaliation or status consequences
  
• Lack of confidence in employer response (52% of lawyers rated employer responses as ineffective)
  
• Employer dismissal of complaints, labeling victims as "troublemakers"
  
• Cultural norms that normalize bullying as "just part of the profession"
  

Shockingly, 96% of bullies faced no consequences, reinforcing a cycle where aggressive behaviors persist unchecked.

What Can Law Firms and Legal Employers Do?

Implement Strong Anti-Bullying Policies

• Clearly define bullying behaviors with examples.
  
• Establish confidential, retaliation-free reporting mechanisms.
  
• Implement structured investigation procedures and consequences.
  
• Regularly communicate anti-bullying commitments to employees.
  

Provide Mandatory Training

• Conduct annual anti-bullying training, including real-world scenarios.
  
• Train leaders and supervisors on fostering a respectful culture.
  
• Educate lawyers on the difference between constructive criticism and bullying.

Encourage Bystander Intervention

• Promote a culture where colleagues speak up when they witness bullying.
  
• Offer training on safe intervention strategies.
  
• Recognize and reward lawyers who contribute to a positive workplace culture.

How Can the Court System Address Bullying?

Judicial Training and Standards

• Implement court-wide anti-bullying rules to set clear expectations.
  
• Train judges to identify and address bullying in courtrooms.
  
• Encourage judges to enforce sanctions against bullying behaviors.

Strengthen Professional Conduct Rules

• Bar associations should establish guidelines for civility in legal proceedings.
  
• Enforce disciplinary measures against repeat offenders.
  
• Implement statewide initiatives similar to Illinois' judicial training efforts.

What Can Individual Lawyers Do?

Report and Document Bullying

• Keep a written record of incidents, including dates and witnesses.
  
• Report bullying through official channels if available.
  
• Seek mentorship or support networks outside the firm.

Be Proactive in Addressing Bullying

• Rehearse responses to common bullying tactics.
  
• Speak up when witnessing bullying behavior.
  
• Advocate for organizational change and anti-bullying policies.

How Can the Court System Address Bullying?

• Bullying in the legal profession is a systemic problem, affecting lawyers of all demographics.
  
• Power imbalances and cultural norms allow bullying to persist unchecked.
  
• Legal employers must implement anti-bullying policies, training, and accountability measures to create a healthier work environment.
  
• Judges and bar associations should establish clear anti-bullying standards to regulate courtroom and professional behavior.
  
• Lawyers must take action by reporting, documenting, and addressing bullying behaviors in their workplaces and legal communities.

Further Your Legal Education With Lawline Courses

Interested in learning more strategies and tips for becoming a better lawyer? Lawline offers a wide assortment of informative continuing education courses that allow you to develop your expertise and take charge of your professional growth. Check out our programs covering more than 60 practice areas and sign up for a free trial today.

Stay up to date! Receive updates on new content, promotions, and more: